'Executing Puente would be like executing your grandmother', one juror is reported to have said in response to the death sentence looming over the defendant at the time. Maybe I would have been better off. Dorothea followed up the drugging by carrying out the . Going to church every day. At the time, she was serving two life sentences and a concurrent 15-year-to-life sentence. Procedural wrangling moved the trial to Monterey, after a judge ruled that the intense media coverage of Puente in the Sacramento region would preclude her from receiving a fair trial here. All three revolve around murder, a fact she notes without irony or self-consciousness. Im not that kind of person. I prod for more, to no avail. Dorothea Montalvo Puente (hereinafter "Petitioner") petitions for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C 2254 challenging her 1993 conviction following a trial by jury. A gentle bear of a man, the 52-year-old Montoya suffered from untreated psychosis, a condition that for years had consigned him to the streets and homeless shelters. I made them change their clothes every day, take a bath every day and eat three meals a day When they came to me, they were so sick, they werent expected to live.. She wound up serving four months in jail and shortly afterward fled Riverside County, flouting the terms of her probation. Arrested for the scam in 1978, court records show, she received five years federal probation, the terms of which proscribed her from operating a boardinghouse. The advanced state of decay, meanwhile, suggested the person had died long before Montoyas presumed disappearance in August. The Boarding House Killer: Directed by Steve Allen. Puente told them that they were welcome to do so, and even provided an extra shovel. Puente offered a place where they could hang on. Petitioner raises several claims and a request for a federal evidentiary hearing. Silver-haired, dressed in a long red coat and wearing large rounded glasses, the 59-year-old resembled just a regular grandmother - proving looks truly can be deceiving. Soon after, Monroe died from an overdose of codeine and acetaminophen. In 1993, after several days of deliberations and a deadlocked jury (due in part to her grandmotherly disposition), Dorothea Puente was ultimately convicted of three murders and received back-to-back life sentences. The string of thefts led to her arrest, and in 1982, a Superior Court judge sentenced her to five years in prison at the California Institution for Women in Corona. Over the next few years, she adapted by working as an in-home caregiver, affecting a matronly mien with her modest dress, oversized glasses and tremulous voice. Despite this, their marriage lasted until 1966. Some months earlier, another tenant, a longtime alcoholic on a bender, had vanished after Puente went to his room to make him feel better. The acrid stench of rotting flesh soon spread through the home and beyond, an odor she blamed on sewer problems and that drew complaints from neighbors. Dorothea Puente looked like a sweet grandmother but looks can be deceiving. A year later her mother died in a motorcycle accident. Authorities alleged that, by poisoning her boarders, she wanted to collect their benefits checks without risk of them notifying social workers or police. In any case, after more than 20 years behind bars, and despite the withering of her features, she retains a physical vitality and a fondness for cosmetic excess. Dorothea Puente, la abuela asesina y su 'casa de la muerte' [19] It was then the subject of the 2015 documentary short The House Is Innocent and was again opened to tours for one day in conjunction with a local film festival's showing of the film.[20]. It was always moving. Puente had welcomed him into her home that February. Seven bodies were eventually found buried on the property.[10]. Between 1982 and 1988, she killed nine people, all of whom were renting rooms at her boarding house. After Puente was released from her first spell in prison for three counts. For years, the disappearances of these so-called shadow people who lived at the margins of society went unnoticed. 'Death House Landlady' Dorothea Puente possessed 'a black heart Puente's deceptive appearance would later go on to confuse the jury presiding over her trial. Dorothea Puente From Netflix's 'Worst Roommate Ever' Was - Bustle While there, doctors diagnosed her as a pathological liar with an unstable personality. She came on a little hard, what with her questions about his Social Security benefits and abrupt suggestion that they consider living together. The Montoya file landed on Cabreras desk within a day. She changed her public image to that of a respectable older matron by putting on vintage clothing, wearing large granny glasses, and letting her hair turn gray. She purchased the refills through a pair of doctors who, presumably oblivious to her past drugging of clients, trusted her stories that she simply wanted to help boarders sleep. She recalls the future president and his first wife, Jane Wyman, as her good friends. When I mention the Gippers second wife, she frowns. At the same time, they agreed she had an evil side brought on by the stress of caring for her down-and-out tenants. Chief later dismantled a garage in the backyard and installed a fresh concrete slab there as well. Those cases were lies, she says, voice flat. See that one? she asks, nodding toward a gaunt, gray-haired woman with stooped posture. (Details of reports on such incidents are not public record.) An extensive five-day search for the elderly fugitive ended when a stranger she'd befriended in Los Angeles recognized her face from the news and turned her into police. Hes not a flirt.. Despite maintaining her innocence until the day she died, Puente has been immortalized as one of America's most notorious female serial killers. During this period, parole agents visited Puente at least fifteen times; though she had been ordered to keep away from the elderly and refrain from handling government checks, no violations were ever noted. Once, when I asked if she ever hears from her surviving siblings or two daughters, she shook her head. "KRON Newscenter 4 11/13/88 Part 1 of 2", Last edited on 18 February 2023, at 18:08, List of serial killers in the United States, List of serial killers by number of victims, "Death House Landlady Got Drugs From Doctor, Prosecutors Contend", "Dorothea Puente dies at 82; boarding house operator who killed tenants", "Guide to the California Superior Court (Sacramento County) case files for The People v. Dorothea Montalvo Puente (criminal case #18056) CNTY0004", "Dorothea Puente and the Boarding House of Death", "Watch Worst Roommate Ever | Netflix Official Site", "In Print: Dorothea Puente's killer cookbook", "Sacramento serial killer's former home renovated, ready for visits", "Tours, documentary focus on Sacramento house of murderer Dorothea Puente", "No Cause Determined in Deaths of Boarders", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dorothea_Puente&oldid=1140147573. READ: Serial Killer Puente's Former Home Becomes Classroom For Law. She was the sixth of seven children but didn't grow up in a stable family environment. After sixteen months, the couple separated, with Gray citing domestic abuse. The Untold Truth Of Dorothea Puente, The Death House Landlady - Grunge.com Watch Worst Roommate Ever | Netflix Official Site I dont think anyone would pick this kind of life, she says, drying tears with a piece of coarse brown paper towel. 104-107. She had breached her federal probation by running a boardinghouse, yet admitted to the offense when asked. [citation needed], O'Mara called over 130 witnesses; he argued to the jury that Puente had used sleeping pills to put her tenants to sleep, then suffocated them, and hired convicts to dig the holes in her yard. Through her early teen years, young Dorothea found herself handed off to a series of relatives and foster homes, bouncing between Napa and Los Angeles, court records reveal. Finding nothing, they asked permission to dig up the yard. With age and health concerns relieving her of work duty, she considers her self-assigned morning chores, attending chapel and other diversions a means of survival. The inmates know who she is, the official says. The Victorian on F Street. Puente has told me during previous meetings that her case still attracts worldwide attention, and that she recently spurned interview requests from a British newspaper and an Australian TV station. Her bedroom was on the second floor. Rene C. Byer Sacramento Bee file. Puente had stayed poised a day earlier when Cabrera showed up with a fellow homicide detective and a federal probation agent. (Photo by Jeremy Sykes). In the narrative of her life that unfurled at her murder trial and in news reports and books about the case, she grew up poor, deprived in equal measure of material comforts and parental nurturing. Cabrera scrambled out of the hole, pulse rate and thoughts quickening. Would you want that to happen to your children? Thats just too much coincidence., Finally, on the 24th day of deliberations, the holdout juror acquiesced, voting guilty on two counts of first-degree murder and one second-degree count. In 2004, she released a cookbook titled Cooking with a . Look at Job, John, Paul, Moses. Some were in an almost mummified state, wrapped tight with cloth, bed sheets and duct tape. With Bill Courage, John Cabrera, Bill Clausen, Judy Moises. Inmates enter one at a time at irregular intervals through a gray metal door along the rear wall. ), Puente relates that, as a Rockette, she met John Kennedy, then a U.S. senator, and his wife, Jackie, and befriended actress Rita Hayworth. I stroll up the paved outdoor path that runs between the check-in station and the visitors hall, a walkway flanked with manicured rose bushes of the sort Puente once might have planted and pruned. That is a human quality that deserves to be preserved. She sits erect, legs crossed at the ankles and tucked beneath her chair. She was just pure evil, Ballenger says. But, behind the scenes, Puente had embarked on a path that would lead her to murder. William Vicary spoke with Puente for the first time about two months after her arrest. The two would continue to have a turbulent relationship, and Gray filed a restraining order in 1975. Dorothea Puente Wrote 'Cooking With A Serial Killer' While - Yahoo Dorothea Puente - Dorothea Helen Puente (January 9, 1929 - March 27, 2011) was an American convicted serial killer. Puente died of natural causes at the Central . She trails Cabrera, his police badge clipped to the front of a dark blue jacket and his jeans tucked into knee-high black boots that he had donned for the days dig. She professed her innocence until she died. EXCLUSIVE: 'I killed JonBent Ramsey! Convicted pedophile Rose West's son breaks silenceto tell how his killer mother Isabel Oakeshott receives 'menacing' message from Matt Hancock, Insane moment river of rocks falls onto Malibu Canyon in CA, Mom who lost both sons to fentanyl blasts laughing Biden, Pavement where disabled woman gestured at cyclist before fatal crash, Pro-Ukrainian drone lands on Russian spy planes exposing location, 'Buster is next!' They wanted to question her about Bert Montoya, her onetime tenant who had been reported missing. It is a flame of humanity that has burned inside Dorothea since she was young That is reason to give Dorothea Puente life without the possibility of parole. The family suspected Puente of poisoning her. Sitting knee to knee, they stare without speaking, eyes wet. These entities fall through the cracks, said Kathleen Lammers, executive director of the California Law Center on Longterm Care, about boarding houses like Puentes. Exploiting her appearance of the sweet old lady, Puente would lure unsuspecting tenants to their grisly deaths by baking them cakes laced with sleeping pills. Puente and McCauley had caught a cab from the Clarion Hotel to a West Sacramento bar. Her statement hangs between us. I have read books and hundreds of news articles and file after file of court records related to her crimes. She gave birth to a daughter in 1946 followed by a second less than a year later, but public documents suggest she inherited her mothers aversion to childrearing. Explaining away the corpses in her yard, she says, Not one person who worked for me saw me doing anything wrong. Puente was acquitted in the poisoning death of his mother, Ruth Munroe, and Clausen, who testified at trial, regards the convicted killers every living day as a denigration of his mothers memory. Some of the remains were in a mummified state - bound in bed sheets, cloth and duct tape (above), Puente would lure her victims to their deaths by baking them cake laced with sleeping pills. After her mother passing Dorothea and her 18 siblings . Others wave and smile. The penalty phase of the prosecution was highlighted by her prior convictions introduced by O'Mara. Be Careful of the Quiet Ones 45m When college student Maribel Ramos goes missing, detectives turn their focus to her roommate, K.C. On New Years Day, a fisherman spotted the box, noticed that it looked suspiciously like a coffin, and informed the police. I have also done this: Late at night, when it is said her deeds turned darkest, I have pondered the vastness of human nature as I stood outside the tiny yard where she buried her victims. Dorothea Puente, born Dorothea Helen Gray was born on January 9, 1929 in San Bernardino County, California. Instead, Puente found a husband. [1] Puente's total count reached nine murders; she was convicted of three and the jury hung on the other six. But eventually, police searching for a missing tenant spotted a patch of disturbed dirt near the boarding house and uncovered the first of several bodies. He escorted her out of the propertys wrought-iron front gate, a moment captured in a photo lying on the conference table. So we knew wed have an uphill battle in convincing the jurors that all of those were accidental deaths.. I discovered 'sweet little granny' was a psychotic serial killer who For William Clausen, by contrast, the bodies buried in Puentes yard confirmed what he already considered fact: she killed for profit. Ill be waiting for her.. Their theory hardened into subjective truth when they discovered that, following the funeral, the nurse had drained thousands of dollars belonging to Munroe from a joint business bank account. Cops hauling away body bags. Puente was born Dorothea Helen Gray on January 9, 1929. She lost her life in a motorcycle wreck the same year, orphaning Dorothea before she turned 10. Speaking softly, she asked, Am I under arrest? When the detective told her no, she explained that the police presence and the growing mob of onlookers had her on edge. [citation needed], In November 1985, Puente hired a man named Ismael Florez to install some wood paneling in her apartment. On her way back, she insisted to reporters that she hadnt killed anyone, claiming: I used to be a very good person at one time.. Many of them found dead and buried in the boarding house's yard. How Did Dorothea Puente Kill Her Victims? Know Her Death House Now High-profile cases dotted his career, including those of convicted mass murderer Morris Solomon and the Unabomber. [citation needed], The defense called several witnesses, who showed Puente had a generous and caring side to her. There are so many sad stories in here. Shes making me lie for her.. 13, as designated by the plastic placard atop its faux-wood surface. Who was Sacramento serial killer Dorothea Puente? | abc10.com - KXTV Hard living had stolen much of Dorotheas youthful beauty by the time she landed her third husband in 1968 and settled in Sacramento. She watched from her porch, and before Cabrera put spade to soil, she requested a moment of his time. Grandson of killer granny Dorothea Puente, who laced cakes with sleeping pills and then smothered them at her California boarding house, reveals how he shared a 'real connection' with her and. Sharp also told police that Puente had hired prisoners on work furlough to dig and fill large holes in the backyard, and that some of the holes were covered with concrete. In the spring of 1948, Gray was arrested for purchasing women's accessories using forged checks in Riverside. And she didnt buy Puentes explanation that hed left on vacation. "You have heard of the despair which was the foundation of her life, the anger and resentmentIf anyone in the jury room tells you it was not that bad, ask them would you want that to happen to yourself? [citation needed]. I wonder if she ever wishes she had received the death penalty. Under the law, Puente received life without the possibility of parole. The police returned and searched the house. In June 2020, the house was featured in a ten-minute documentary with 60 Second Docs about the purchase and renovation of the house by the current owners. Now she watched from her second-story porch as the trio began to dig. The visitors hall at the Central California Womens Facility in Chowchilla brings to mind a church social as hosted for state convicts.